The Love Hypothesis

The Love Hypothesis is a romcom based on the novel of the same name, which is itself an adaptation of Head Over Feet, which centers on a Ph.D. student and a graduate professor from Stanford University falling in love whilst pretending to be dating for mutually beneficial reasons. It’s one of the oldest tricks in the book, and that does not mean it is a bad thing.

Somebody once said that enemies to lovers requires absolute loathing between the main leads and that many stories that entertain the trope fail to accurately reflect that. It begs the question: what would those same people say about “fake dating”? The Love Hypothesis feels like it could be a mixture of those two tropes, but it ultimately is not enemies to lovers. Olive Smith (Lili Reinhart) and Dr. Adam Carlsen (Tom Bateman) do not hate one another. They don’t even loathe one another. They simply don’t get along because Dr. Carlsen, known around Stanford University as “Dr. Evil,” does not get along with anybody. Yet their chemistry is undeniable, and it is, in the end, precisely why people tuned in to watch this film.

There was a time when fanfiction was niche. While all art can be considered a passion and much of it can be created by one person, fanfiction is the kind of passion project that requires dedication because it can never make money. Those days are gone, and The Love Hypothesis isn’t even the first fanfiction story to become a major motion picture. Hilariously, it, and every single one that most people can name, never will be—it’s Fifty Shades if you’re curious—but that doesn’t undermine the impact. And yet, this is the first that had the audacity to cast the husband of the actress for whom the female lead was inspired.

The source material for The Love Hypothesis is Star Wars, and the two leads are based on Kylo Ren and Rey, two leads from the Star Wars Sequel Trilogy who did have a rather spectacular “will-they-won’t-they” enemies-to-lovers storyline that, in the end, did not result in the pair getting together. While I haven’t read the original book or the fanfiction that inspired it—and inspired is the term that has to be used because fanfiction cannot be used to make money—I have seen the films that resulted in Head Over Feet. The inspiration is clear and the divergence intriguing. The context for a Star Wars “love” story involving one half of the potential couple attempting to kill the other doesn’t exactly translate too well to any other kind of genre.

The first time that Olive and Dr. Carlsen technically meet is right before Olive is set to interview for Stanford’s Ph.D. program. Nervous and wearing expired contact lenses, Olive slips into a bathroom to deal with her blurred vision and is confronted by a man that she cannot see who offers her encouragement in the same beat that he tells her that she is in a private bathroom usable only by him and people on his team.

Olive’s anxiety stems from a longstanding fear of public speaking when it comes to presenting her material, especially when the people she is presenting it to can control the future of her research and her admission. Dr. Carlsen’s encouragement is what helps carry her through that process, though Olive never learns his identity until years later.

By the time the film properly begins, Olive is two years into her program, and Dr. Carlsen’s reputation is well established. We see much of this time through a helpful montage which introduces three very critical people to Olive’s life. While she sees Jeremy Langley (Nicholas Duvernay) first, Ahn (Rachel Marsh) is by far the most important friendship that Olive makes in those first few days. Malcolm (Jaboukie Young-White) is the third and final member that fills out Olive’s friend group.

Ahn is outspoken and dependable and absolutely the reason that the plot of The Love Hypothesis truly kicks in. Jeremy exists in a gray zone. At first, Olive’s crush on him seems like it might have something, but it quickly becomes clear that Jeremy is interested in Ahn. The problem stems from the fact that Ahn is not blind and knows that Olive has feelings for Jeremy, even if Jeremy is seemingly oblivious to them. Nobody can deny that Olive is pretty and the brief looks between Olive and Jeremy hint that something could happen, but Olive realizes the truth within weeks of spending time with them.

When Ahn refuses Jeremy’s advances out of solidarity for her friendship with Olive, Olive quickly throws out that she already has a date and has moved on from Jeremy. Ahn is doubtful, if not outright suspicious, about the timing, prompting Olive to expand the lie and claim that she has a date that very night. When Olive should be on said date, she is actually in the lab working. When Ahn returns to the lab early, Olive panics and rushes out and kisses the first man that she sees: Adam Carlsen.

Adam’s prickly nature puts things on unstable ground after that first kiss in self-defense, but his own need to convince the people who will determine whether his program continues being funded pushes him to orchestrate the fake dating situation with Olive. The film is coy for a while about how both Olive and Adam genuinely feel about one another, allowing us to wonder if they actually love one another for quite a while. The tension between them is blatant, but just like that flirtatious look that Jeremy gave Olive on day one, there is the possibility that both of them are seeing what they want to see and not what is actually happening.

The people around them include Dr. Thomas Benton (Art Froushan), who is an old friend of Adam’s and becomes interested in Olive’s work. Dr. Juliet Aslan (Jeananne Goossen) is a professor at Stanford who is encouraging of Olive’s efforts and, in the end, proves to be her salvation. Dr. Fastuca (Aladeen Tawfeek), Adam’s department head and the man standing between Adam’s funding being renewed, is one of the people Adam and Olive have to convince that their relationship is real.

Fake dating is an interesting trope. Its effectiveness lies in the justification. In this case, Olive and Adam’s goals are chronologically dependent on one another but not mutually dependent on one another. The longer that Olive is dating Adam, the more time Ahn and Jeremy have to form a genuine romantic attachment. The more serious the relationship looks from the outside, the more time that Adam has to prove that he has put down roots in California. Their plan requires them to appear publicly with one another at two different kinds of events because they are in two different life stages.

Olive is a grad student, and Adam is a postdoc, and while they are both adults, the expectations are not the same. But they are close enough in age that they can find common ground. It is the fact that Olive is still a student, despite her age, that puts their perspectives at odds. Olive is still at a stage in her life where drinking parties are not out of the ordinary. Adam is at a stage of his life where predictability is his friend—more so since the film declined to adapt a character who was his actual friend. The actors actually having a similar age gap between them worked in this film’s favor, as far as I’m concerned.

Amazon has been on a spending spree. It has been buying up books left, right, and center to adapt them, and the young adult novels have garnered particular attention over the last year. Why some become films and others television shows is something that can only be determined by the people involved. I will always believe that a book is better served being adapted into a television show than a movie, while simultaneously appreciating a good movie. The Love Hypothesis was a fun movie, and with the book’s sequel set to come out next year, we shall see if it made enough of an impact for Amazon to commit to it, too.

Leave a Reply

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close